Competitive Intelligence Tool

Black Hat —
Competitive Review

Structured competitive analysis for pre-bid decision-making

AI-supported competitive review providing structured, human-led decision support for early-stage bidding. Combines AI-generated insight with validated judgement to assess opportunities, competitors, capability gaps, risks, and strategic direction.

Worked example — evaluation report Phase 1 model
Digital-enabled engineering training programme
Capability areaScoreImpact
Engineering training delivery4/5High
Digital / simulation capability2/5High
Scalability3/5Medium
Commercial competitiveness4/5High
Customer access and influence3/5Medium
Proceed with Caution

Illustrative worked example — Phase 1 operational model


How it works

Four stages.
One decision.

1
Stage 1
What are we assessing?

Define the opportunity, market position, and initial competitor awareness. You are in control of the framing.

AI minimalHuman leads
2
Stage 2
What does winning look like?

AI generates competitor hypotheses and assessment dimensions. You review, challenge, and confirm before anything is accepted.

AI generatesHuman validates
3
Stage 3
How credible are we?

AI proposes initial capability scores. You validate, amend, and apply the organisational knowledge that no AI can hold.

AI proposesHuman confirms
4
Stage 4
What should we do next?

AI synthesises and challenges. You make the decision, own the rationale, and record the strategic actions.

AI supportsHuman decides

What you will need

Come prepared.
The tool works with what you bring.

01 — Opportunity

The opportunity reference, customer name, estimated contract value, and procurement type.

02 — Strategic intent

Your initial view on where you stand: actively pursuing, exploring, or monitoring.

03 — Competitors

Up to four competitors you expect to see on this opportunity, and what you know about them.

04 — Win position

Your current win themes or early sense of why the customer should choose you.

05 — Capability

An honest view of your own capability in the areas that matter for this bid.

06 — Intelligence

Any prior intelligence, lessons learned, or market insight relevant to this customer or sector.

Preparation documents are available to help you gather inputs before your session. Use the Helpful Documents link to download stage-by-stage worksheets.

What the tool produces

Three possible outcomes.
All well-founded.

Proceed

The opportunity is attractive and you are well placed to win. Commit to a full bid on the current strategy.

Proceed with Caution

The opportunity is viable but material risks or gaps exist that require active mitigation before or during bid development.

Withdraw

The risks outweigh the potential benefits, or the organisation is not sufficiently well placed to win on any credible strategy.

The decision is always yours. The tool exists to make sure it is well-founded. All reports carry a Commercial — In Confidence classification.


Get started

Ready to begin?

New review

Start a review

Begin a four-stage review from scratch. You will be prompted to authenticate before Stage 1 begins.

Start new review
Preparation

Helpful documents

Download stage-by-stage preparation worksheets to gather your inputs before your session.

View documents

This tool is available to approved users. Clicking Start new review will prompt you to authenticate. If you do not have access, contact john@dynes-insights.com.